As the school makes preparations for students and more staff members to return to campus, safety is the biggest concern. (Photo by Katelyn Mandell)
As the school makes preparations for students and more staff members to return to campus, safety is the biggest concern.

Photo by Katelyn Mandell

Online or on campus? Students debate over the future of our school year

Almost a full year of remote learning and the conversation of whether or not students should return to school has become more pressing than ever.

March 7, 2021


Photo by Malia Brame

Although some students want to go back to school, staying online does have its benefits.

The benefits of distanced learning and why we should not go back on campus

Since March 13th 2020, the San Marcos Unified School District (SMUSD) has been using distance learning to school students, with the exception of elementary schools following a hybrid schedule. Many students long to go back to physical school, however, staying online has many benefits for students and the community.
One obvious reason to continue with distance learning is the surge in coronavirus cases not only in California but also in San Diego County, which has a total of 262,000 reported cases. Going back to school would threaten the health of teachers, students, and potentially their family members. Our number one priority should be the health and safety of our staff and students, so it should be crucial that we continue distance learning.
“I believe that it’s important for us to continue online school for all of our safety and so that none of us catch the virus and continue the spread,” junior Sophie Lemus said.
While learning at home, students don’t have to worry about transportation to and from school, but it could be an issue during physical school for students who have to walk or take the bus to campus. If we went back to school in person, these students might struggle with the new COVID-19 guidelines that allow for less space available on public transportation.
Since distance learning means that we do all of our work from home, parents have more opportunities to be involved with their children’s education. Parents and guardians now have a chance to see what students’ classes are like instead of having to rely 100% on emails or their children’s communication. And with the help of parents being able to watch their classes in real-time, students can get assistance with issues and alleviate any confusion caused by distance learning.
“Even though many of us still aren’t comfortable with online learning, it prevents students and teachers from getting covid since there is a possibility of more spreading when we go back,” junior Arely Carretero said.
Another plus of continuing distance learning is the continuation of a customized curriculum. Staying home means more time for extracurriculars and receiving help in the areas that suit students’ needs. In SMUSD’s case, the 4×4 class schedule system allows for more credits to be earned in one school year than a student could have normally. With an extra class period each term, students can now get tutoring during school hours, work towards early graduation, and even earn more college credits by taking more AP classes.
Next time you feel down about having to stay home for school, think about all the positives that can come from the situation. Continuing distance learning instead of going back to in-person school is an opportunity for new hobbies, friends, and further education for students, all while keeping the community safe.


Photo by Victor Bautista

After a year at home, students want to go back on campus.

The negative affects of distanced learning and why we should go back on campus

As we near the one-year anniversary of our departure from normal school life, many students are anxious to reclaim the normalcy that COVID-19 has taken from them. Students miss their friends, teachers miss their students, and parents miss having time away from their kids; there is a push from many groups for students to return to in-person classes. Due to distance learning’s toll on the mental health of students as well as the strain that it has put on their academic performance, MHHS students should, under optimal conditions of course, return to campus ASAP.
“I think we should return to campus due to the amount of high schoolers suffering because they have no support system… So many kids aren’t showing up to class and suicide/depression rates are on the rise. I truly think that in-person school is so much more beneficial to kids struggling! At MHHS kids can find friends, teachers, counselors, food, resources, et cetera. I really think that it would be more harm than good to keep students from campus any longer,” senior Kellianne Knox said.
The return date for on-campus classes that was set on the 19th of January was cancelled, and with a vaccine now getting circulated and COVID numbers beginning to stagnate, many students and parents are looking forward to returning to a “normal” school environment. For many students, the distanced learning format was detrimental to their academic performance. Students received insufficient instructions from teachers which developed into an apathy for school. The isolation felt by high schoolers, many of whom lack the abundance of socialization they used to have at school and the interactions with their peers, has led to a sharp decline in overall mental health.
“I think we should go back as soon as possible because it’s bad for our students’ mental health, especially in these teenage years. The school tells us to socially engage with other people but with distant learning everyone’s cameras are off and we barely talk. We don’t even get the chance to socialize,” sophomore Savannah Persing said.
While many students are anxious to return to their normal school life, many also believe that it is far too risky to return during the 2020-2021 school year. Most students miss their friends, their teachers, and everything that they lost back in March, but they understand that perhaps it would be best to stay home and finish the school year virtually. To many, there’s no point in risking spikes in COVID cases and further shutdowns when we’re already in the second term and are so close to the end of the year. Had you asked if they should return back in August, you would have gotten a different answer.
Students’ apprehensions towards a return to in-person classes are valid, but the alarming decline in teenagers’ mental health is an important factor to consider. Seniors, who had been crushed by the loss of their senior year, are experiencing a heightened sense of disinterest towards school. Juniors, who are having their hardest academic year, are speeding through lessons without enough instruction or information on the subject. Furthermore, freshmen and sophomores are losing years vital to their overall high school experience. Not to mention that the burnout faced by students is extremely detrimental to their academic performance, with distractions like family members and slow wifi tanking their interest in school. Many students could be left wondering what the point of paying attention even is.
“I also believe distance learning has impacted kids very negatively. Even in myself I’ve noticed a lack of motivation and willpower to even wake up and join class. We have been kept away from normalcy for so long and I think it’s time to get just a little bit back,” Knox continued.
For reasons other than students simply missing normal life, it is imperative that MHHS returns to campus as soon as possible. But with numbers still high and San Marcos’ position in the Purple Tier unwavering, many students are apprehensive to return to campus. There is the fear of numbers rising and cases spreading, resulting in further lockdowns and a push back of sports and school activities. Nonetheless, the need for stability and social interaction with peers along with the subpar performance of distanced lessons is as impactful as ever. Hopes are high that if we drop down into the Red Tier, our plans for a return to in-person classes will begin.

The Silvertip • Copyright 2023 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in